I say Half-Life 2 for PC game of the year.
MGS3 for Console game of the year.
Considering that PC and Console games are still very different in play style and content its hard to pit them against one another.
However, when compairing FPS games, I’m going to bet that Halo2 MAY win out just cause of the retard hype. Many many many people will not know how much better Halflife 2 is than Halo2… Oh well. Either way, yes Half-Life 2 deserves game of the year. And… Well, I fucking loved MGS3 so I cant say it doesnt either!
Both HL2 and Halo2 have had lots of hype. Its just a person’s style, really. Me, I don’t really see whats so spectacular about Halo. Good, but not quite worthy of the praise it recieves. But I know people more intelligent than ‘OMGTWFBBQ IT LIK RULZ’ idiots, and still love it, so I can respect that its more preference.