The following statement is based off personal observation. Nothing more, nothing less.
These smileys seem to be the least-used ones:
:boring: p:unch:: :runaway: ::doh::
I love you Gizamaluke, forgot about that funky banana. We need the black mage doing the cabbage patch dance.
-cactuar running, tonberry, chocobo, chanting of spell sprite
kentucky fried chocobo wee, now only if it could work if smaller doh
http://www.bwoup.com/sprites.html The cheerleader girl, smiley blowing its brains out, and the lobster sprite
-river city ransom
-megaman?
-the Golden idol or statue from earthbound
-evil cat with glowing red eyes…hint angered sparkles
-a cookie
-Nulani’s smilies
-super mario ghost boo?
-south park
-mortal kombat
-pacman
-street fighter
Yes we have a sad smiley, but how can you not love bowser crying?
http://www.vgws.com/emu/sprite.html
http://www.planetdreamcast.com/psoworld/bbcode_ref.php the spam is from this site
http://www.gamingforce.com/forums/misc.php?action=showsmilies
No i am not wanting all the smilies and spirites from each page i listed, the 24 smileys that we have now are fine. Just sites and ideas for other people to look at and suggest more smileys.
Am i the only one that likes Frog hopping away smiley?
Edit: damn you tripod and you evil x.
hmpf, i know what we have; that doesn’t mean they can’t be replaced
I might as well repeat it here. I want the crying bowser from SM RPG 
I second that one! XD
Here’s a different Booster one that looks cool.
Hint man image with transparency.
And just for Sin, a crying Bowser.
I third the banana and second/third crying bowser.
<img src=“http://www.rpgclassics.com/staff/hiryuu/scream.gif”>
<img src=“http://www.rpgclassics.com/staff/hiryuu/yawn.gif”>
<img src=“http://www.rpgclassics.com/staff/hiryuu/spank.gif”>
And while you’re at it, replace the current Flea smiley with one that has a bit more movement:
<img src=“http://www.rpgclassics.com/staff/hiryuu/kissy.gif”>
Haha, I like the crying Bowser too.
Can someone who knows how to animate that?
BLAMMO!!!
My vote for that one. Best smilie ever.
And that: <img src = “http://uploads.nulani.net/uploads/salamando4.gif”>
My vote is for Hint Guy and Crying Bowser. Plus these two:
<img src=‘http://www.rpgclassics.com/~onlinelife/images/Ebidance.gif’>
<img src=‘http://www.rpgclassics.com/~onlinelife/images/Boxers.png’>
…what?
I did a quick Google and found an animated version. 
YES. We should have that one.
I’m all for making :kissy: animated, just keep it facing this way >.>;; Also, make :victoly: animated aswell. No removing Lucca, she is damned sexy.
… and what is :moogle: for? it seems uhh… yeah >.>; maybe replace moogle with something like hint.
:kissy:
How about replace nothing and just add stuf? 
::dekar!:: hugglies dekar
Hmmm… Let me see if I can find something too…
is worthy, the rest are bleh.