But FFVI is not what most of us consider old either. If I think oldschool, I think Dragon Warrior 1 and Final Fantasy 1 and Phantasy Star 1. Those old, linear, simplistic and torturously buttraping jewels of old that we went through as little kids.
FFVI was pretty much a revolution. While IV was really the point of change between “let’s make the game as impossible as we can” and “let’s make the game enjoyable and with a good story”, VI (Lets remember, V had never been translated) was probably the best execution of this style we had ever seen until then. And the peasants rejoiced.
But then came VII, and the response was split. Old fans were reasonably impressed by the graphics, but didn’t feel that amazed by a story and gameplay that wasn’t necessarily superior to its predecessor. We still went WOAH! like everyone else, but not quite at the same level as people who were introduced to gaming through this title.
Now, why FFVII and VIII don’t need remakes? In VII’s case, while backgrounds and everything else was pretty, I’ll concede the character avatars were simply awful. Seriously, the FFVI sprites are more emotive than those jumbled polygons. They still didn’t know how to work in 3D and that could use a fixing. The problem is that most of us are getting goddamn sick of VII after a movie, a shooter, a phone game, and the announcement of a vaporous PSP title. The general consent is: “Knock it off and work on something new!”. Especially since some of us also consider that FFVII didn’t really deserve this much expansion as much as other titles did.
FFVIII is much simpler: What would you remake? Seriously, what? Square already had a good grasp on 3D graphics by then and the effect was amazing. The leap between VII and VIII was huge as far as graphic quality is concerned; so much that FFIX didn’t even improve them that much beyond minor polishing. What would you add besides voice acting? There’s absolutely no reason to remake the game.
EDIT: Holy shit, that went a lot longer than I expected O_o