The other day I was at a meeting with the school paper I work for, and got into an argument with the team’s “gentle rebel without a cause”.
Stop going “<I>Weiila</I> got in an argument? WTF?” please. :kissy:
His points were that your school grades won’t be worth much on the job market since it’s your actual skills that count.
I hate to agree, but it’s pretty accurate.
However, then he claimed that we should simply cut down the grading system even more, so that people won’t worry so much about their grades and focus on more important things.
I claim that this would not work. While the idea is good in theory, currently Sweden is already using a ridiculously simplified grading system. In college/university, we only have three grades; fail, pass, and pass with distinction. The final one is rather difficult to get in most courses, you need to really prove yourself.
The guy wanted to take away the higher grading, so that you could only fail or pass.
My opinion is simple, if there is nothing above the passing grade, what on earth is there to struggle for to actually study a bit extra, fight a little harder? The pass with distinction is proof that you’ve really tried hard to learn and prove yourself in class and testing.
I have a lot of “pass with distinction” in my luggage, and I’m proud of them all. But I know myself, and many others around me - if we had nothing extra to struggle for, we would not care at all. I have a lazy personality and without a prize to drive me on I may just drop it all.
The guy went on with his views, that if grades aren’t important to a possible employee, what does it matter anyway? “It’s your personal achivements and REAL knowledge, that you’ve aquired out of the classroom, that is important. If you can’t live up to what you’re presenting yourself to be in an interview, the boss will realize it and kick you out soon enough.”
… did you just say that we should flat out lie on job interviews? And what exactly is “REAL” knowledge? How do you prove it? What about us people who aren’t good at making commercials about ourselves? Grades may not prove much, but if you have a lot of pass with distinction it WILL show that you’re a hard worker.
Whatever, I could not get anywhere with him, and neither could the others there who were also arguing against him.
Now I’d like to know what you guys think about this. Are grades really so unimportant that they should be rendered simplistic enough to prove this?