[Speaking of Tifa: can anyone tell me why, when Tifa and Scarlet face each other on top of the Sister Ray, instead of an actual battle we get- a slapfest?? Tifa has been shown all game to be a kickboxing badass, and when she finally gets the chance to kick the vile villainess’s ass all she does is SLAP HER? (If they ever remake this game, I hope they fix that.)
I always thought this was some sort of fetish on the developers’ part.
Actually, is it ever established that Tifa knew Cloud was lying?(I don’t remember if it was when Sephiroth shows the truth at the Crater). He was wearing the guardsmen helmet and mask when he met Tifa in Nibelheim; and as mentioned, didn’t want her to know that he failed to make it into SOLDIER, so he wouldn’t(didn’t) have talked to her. When he did take his helmet off, she was unconscious and wounded.
I think Tifa’s problem was that she had a guilt-trip over Cloud; it was her accident while exploring a cave together that caused him to feel powerless to help her, and thus obsessed with becoming “strong enough to protect her.” Though that was his fault, she didn’t help by encouraging him on. Her attempts to help him -even getting him on Avalanche- always struck me as her trying to make up for it. She also of course had that kind of crush you see often in Anime where two friends want to be more than that but feel it awkward because they know each other since childhood and they’re more like siblings. The irony here is that Tifa herself has become physically powerful -to avenge her father’s death- but is emotionally weak. Yeah, everybody in FFVII had issues. Emo game indeed. But fun.
In real life, people and especially women can get real emotional with the whole ‘childhood crush’ thing. They feel like its a link to their past, to the person they were when they were young, and the feeling of recapturing your lost self can translate into feelings of intimacy and romance for a lot of people. Of course, that’s in real life, not game logic.
Tifa didn’t know Cloud was in Nibelheim, but she definitely did know he wasn’t there as Sephiroth’s right-hand man - that was Zack, whom she’d met. So while she knew he had false memories, she didn’t know what the real ones were.
RPG logic can go screw itself, it was at the very least heavily implied that both Tseng and Rufus had died, if only because they never showed up again. Rufus got hit dead on by a blast from weapon for god’s sake. I didn’t get the impression that FF7 was the kind of game that particularly followed traditional RPG logic - hell, a main character was murdered in front of us.
And a lot of movies/books/plays/comics leave things to conjecture, but there are always at least indications of what form the conjecture should take. A starting point might be given, or implied. With AC there was none of this. It was just them going “Look, this is cool, in it goes.” Which is fine. I enjoyed it. I just don’t consider it canon.
AC doesn’t mesh with the game at all. I hope no one’s arguing that it’s anything more than really cool fan fiction, because that’s pretty oblivious.
Also, was anyone else disappointed in the AC Turks? They’re supposed to be badass, not VII’s Team Rocket.
I was, up until the scene with the tunnel and the bomb. That was awesome.
Shrug Just because it took things in a different direction doesn’t mean it automatically isn’t canon. In fact, that’s impossible given that Square Enix released it and e.g. Dirge of Cerberus assumes it took place. You can argue about its quality all you like but that doesn’t change the fact that it exists. O_o
I think we’ll have to agree to disagree here. Sure there was a lot left open (more than usual) but I don’t agree that translates into there being nothing there in the first place - just that they didn’t have enough screen time to give us all the hints plus all the cool fight scenes, and we all know what takes precedence there. 8p
First off, and to reiterate. The only one who should be looking after Cloud is Barret. I’m almost certain Marlene would appreciate having a new mother.
Originally Posted by Hades Shinigami
[i]Aeris’ limits were good for exactly two things:
- Healing
- Killing Lost Number,[/i]
Second, you forgot about her one Limit that gives itself to another character, it makes learning limit breaks faster for the other characters (though granted it’s not that useful thanks to the effort involved in getting it), but then again I went and used the Wutai area to grind by slapping Fury on everyone and selling off the assload of Turbo Ethers that the local fauna were sweating. When I was finished both Cloud and Yuffie could use Omni-Slash and All Creation respectfully.
Also Seal Evil works against the Turks in the Gongaga forest. It saved my life the first time I took them on.
Originally Posted by Curtis
[i]
Quote:[QUOTE]Originally Posted by Valkyrie Esker View Post
I’d like to point out that when Tifa met Cloud again, and saw he was in a very, very bad state of mind (being convinced they met more recently than she did, etc.) she got him to join a terrorist organization. And later on, when he told a story that she knew DEFINITELY didn’t add up to what she knew? She didn’t say a thing. Frankly, I don’t think I could trust someone like that, especially when Cloud would be dealing with psychological issues the rest of his life after all that crap, and needs an emotional anchor. Whether she really cares for him or not, she definitely isn;t good for him.
Actually, is it ever established that Tifa knew Cloud was lying?(I don’t remember if it was when Sephiroth shows the truth at the Crater). He was wearing the guardsmen helmet and mask when he met Tifa in Nibelheim; and as mentioned, didn’t want her to know that he failed to make it into SOLDIER, so he wouldn’t(didn’t) have talked to her. When he did take his helmet off, she was unconscious and wounded.[/i][/QUOTE]
And finally, to state a probability here. The fact that he was able to give a first-hand account of the events that occurred there with greater accuracy than someone who wasn’t there probably confused the crap out of her until she went into the upside of his spikey white head and found out that he was indeed there.
AC: Somebody wiser than me stated that it’s pretty meh for a movie, but for a music video it’s awesome.
AC flouts almost every inch of plot and character development that took place in the game. Things might look the same cosmetically, but you’re not dealing with the same characters or the same world that FFVII was built on, at all. It’s a good stand-alone movie, but it pretends the game didn’t ever exist. It never mentions or reflects anything from the game beyond having a few of the same-looking characters with the same names. The only city ever mentioned is Midgar. They did this so you could enjoy it without ever playing the game. They’re completely disconnected.
Both takes on Advent Children are correct: it IS in continuity, and meant as a link to the other sequels and spinoffs. On the other hand, the movie itself was done as a way to “recapture” the coolness of the original game (and introduce it for new fans) even if character (and story) progress gets undone in the process; not to mention, to show off what everyone looks like with our new-fangled CGI graphics, ooh! 
I thought it looked cool and was OK to watch, but it was redundant in many ways (Sephiroth AGAIN? Can’t you come up with a new villain? Sheesh.) But at least Cloud got to deal with Aeris’ death (hopefully.)
My opinion of AC is that Square would have been better off just making a movie of
FF7 itself. Which seems to be what they really wanted to do, considering they brought back to life all the old characters, including Sephiroth, so that he and Cloud could have a long, climactic duel that was absent in FF7.
That being said, I do think AC is ‘canon’ and enriches FF7 because clearly it was an attempt to flesh out the characters in ways that Square didn’t have enough time or courage to do in FF7.
If by flesh out you mean tear down and rebuild very shittily from the ground up with no resemblance to the originals beyond sharing the same name and superficial design, I agree.
If AC was really intertwined with FF7 at all, there’d be mention of things that happened in the game. Beyond the existence of a city that looks like and is named “Midgar,” there isn’t. It’s like the characters all have amnesia, and half of them have been resurrected, including someone who was shot in the face by Diamond Weapon in a CG sequence, which we all know you don’t come back from, and someone whose SOUL you removed from the Lifestream. There’s no continuity and no believable connection between the two. It’s SE-endorsed fan fiction.
I agree 100% with Hades on this. I don’t even feel bad about it. And yeah, I know that it’s technically canon. I just choose to believe it isn’t because it’s so horrible if it is.
And I didn’t really think any of the characters were fleshed out in AC. The only one who got screen time where they could flesh him out was Cloud, and the ‘fleshing out’ he got had already being done in game. I guess maybe you could argue Tifa had some development as well, but it was really superficial and made her look much flatter as a character than the game did.
You guys realize, of course, that if Square does remake FFVII (which I’m pretty sure they will) they will likely change things so that it fits in better wth the stuff that has been released since, such as the backstory of Dirge of Cerberus and Crisis Core. So AC likely will be better in-continuity in the future, retrofitted you could say. No, I’m not saying I like the idea, only that I expect Square to do it.
(Of course, if they add MORE stuff to the story, would that mean they would have to take some stuff out? Like maybe things like Gongaga village… other than revealing that it was Zack’s home village, that served no story purpose that I remember.)
Gongaga’s purpose was to show the effects of Shinra’s corporatism on what was essentially a poor, Third World village. It added to the overall ambience of the game.
re: fleshing out characters
I agree a lot with what you guys said, Hades and Cavelcade. On second thought, the only additional character development in AC was some of Cloud’s philosophizing, but even that was vague. Come to think of it, its surprising how much the plot of AC resembles your average bad FF7 fanfic. Rufus and the Turks join forces with the good guys, Cloud talks with Aeris’ spirit, Sephiroth is resurrected for one last battle, etc.
And a lot of it does undercut FF7. Like, how Cloud receives consolation from Aeris’ spirit. That sort of obliterates the whole theme of loss and finality of Aeris’ death from FF7, which caused so many fanboys to think you could bring her back to life.
It turns out you can bring her back to life - you just have to work long enough at sony. 
And the continuity isn’t the problem, Wil, continuity-wise it’s fine. Midgar is destroyed, the world looks fine. They wouldn’t even have to imply Rufus or Tseng survived, they could just leave it as it is - ‘undefined’.
Goddamn this movie was a waste. 
Oh, and Gongaga also gave the first hint you had a spy in your midst, as well as showing the Turks as guys as well as killers.
Cloud/Tifa The plot better than Cloud/Aeris-Aerith. Plus the fact that Tifa is my favorite character! lol
A polyamorous relationship between the three.
