We were talking about this in the chat last night, so I thought I’d post a few links for anyone interested in this stuff.
Overpopulation is no longer the most threatening issue facing China. Actually, China’s growth rate is quite negligible these days: in some places, there are even labor shortages, or at least there were prior to the financial crisis. That’s not really true anymore. The current birth rate in China is about 1.8 children per family, which over the long term would actually lead to a shrinking population over time (you need about 2.1 to 2.2 children per family to break even). The issue now is the growing disparity between boys and girls. For children under the age of 20, there are now 32 million more boys than girls
That is only for children. That is equivalent to the entire male population of France. The disparity also exists among older generations, which has led to a massive surplus of males. Why has this happened? Well, it is pretty much purely the result of the One Child Policy. Male children have always been preferred in China, but previously, women could have as many children as they wanted, so if they had some girls, it didn’t matter. They could get a small dowry for the girls as well down the line. After the one child policy was enacted, however, families that had girl children started to freak out. Who would take care of the family? Luckily, they found an answer. Ultrasound had just recently been invented, which could detect the sex of a child prior to birth. If it was discovered to be female, it could be aborted and the family could try again. The procedure was quickly banned in China, but over here, anything can be had for a small price. The procedure is still commonplace today.
ACtually, the One Child Policy is not as set-in-stone as many believe. Most children in China are not only children. There are 300 million children, but only 60 million are only children. There are a few reasons for this. In the countryside, families that give birth to a girl first may try again for a boy. Families that want a second child can also simply pay a fine to have the child. The fine can range from anywhere to $1,000 to nearly $100,000, depending on the area and how many connections you have. There are also of course cases of twins, triplets, etc.
http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/338/apr09_2/b1211
Some of these statistics are truly shocking. The most shocking to me was that in Anhui province, one of the most poor and rural provinces in China, among second born children the ratio of males to females born is 190 to 100. That is almost 2 males born for every female. The ratio in Shanghai is the lowest at 110 to 100, which is still statistically significant above the world average of 105 to 100. It is quite clear that the policy of allowign second born children to be males is not helping the ratio at all, when figures average about 140 to 150 to 100 for second born children. There is still a lot of sex selection going on.
Of course, this might be better than the alternative. The best estimate is that the one child policy has eliminated anywhere from 300 to 500 million births in China. If we take the middle and say 400 million, that would have increased China’s population today to 1.7 billion instead of 1.3 billion. What is worse? Having 400 million more people, or having 30 million extra boys? I guess I can’t really answer that, but I do disagree a bit with the figure. With China’s booming economy, it’s like that birth rates would have dropped quite significantly anyway, as has been shown time and again in developing economies.
As the article above shows, Children have become more of an investment than a safety net. It is very expensive to have a child in China now. Schools are not free: the good ones are very expensive, even by Western standards. Then there are all of the extra classes. English, swimming, math, cram studying…many have remarked that China no longer allows childhood. As soon as you are able to read, your life consists of 25 years of study, followed by work until death. You might have heard the term “little emperor” or “little empress” This is another outgrowth of the one child policy. Parents project all of their hopes and dreams onto their children. The side effect of this though is that children become despondent and unable to care for themselves, let alone their parents or extended families. Many parents hope their child can perform well on test and study abroad, thereby leading to a potential path for immigration for the whole family.
My favorite line in this whole article is the 15 year old girl who already “dreams of marrying a foreigner”, not for money, but for lifestyle. China’s environment is competitive beyond belief. Friends betray each other to get ahead, relationships are made not on love but on mutual benefit. Young boys and girls read Japanese romance novels and watch Korean soap operas, dreaming of a type of love they can only imagine happening with a “foreigner.” Chinese people, she thinks, are too cunning and practical. As a male foreigner in China, I obviously see this on a very personal level. I’m not bragging when I say that I could literally get 5 or 10 dates in the next 2 minutes if I just casually mention to some of my female coworkers that I’m “looking for a nice girl.” It can be hard not to exploit such a position, I will admit. I’m not saying every girl in China is “begging for a foreigner”, but supply and demand economics are quite clear on the issue. There are far more girls here willing to entertain the prospect of dating a foreigner than there are potential foreign candidates.
http://sun-zoo.com/chinageeks/2009/04/13/male-female-ratio-in-china-trouble-a’-brewin’/
This brings us back around to what I was talking about first. There is already a huge surplus of males. Girls as young as 14 or 15 are already dreaming of marrying a foreigner or getting the hell out of dodge for a better life. What are all of those males going to do?
Well, this article is a bit old, but it’s only gotten worse. One thing that is happening is “wife stealing” Girls are stolen from poor Chinese villages and sold to families who have a boy child as a future wife. The phenomenon is quickly spreading to neibhoring countries as well, mostly Vietnam, Laos, Mongolia, and North Korea. It is, of course, impossible to steal enough women to satisfy demand, and it is a risky venture as well. Authorities are beginning to clamp down hard. I’ve heard a number of possible scenarios. One that is often touted is war. China’s military force is decreasing in size (people anyway, not the budget), however…and anyway, who is China going to fight a conventional war with anyway? Taiwan? It’s honestly not that likely. I’ve also heard that the issue is moot, as about 8% of those males would be homosexual, which is more than the 32 million surplus. Homosexuality is still largely frowned up in Chinese society, however, and most families will still abandon any child who is out of the closet.
Most likely, it will just lead to rising under-the-radar nationalism and increased crime / civil strife. Prostitution has been linked as well to the risign excess male population, which further exacerbates the problem: who wants to marry an ex-prostitute?
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/07/25/AR2008072502255.html
To wrap this up, I have one last article here. China’s population will soon stop growing. While some think this is a good thing, it can have disastrous economic consequences. We need look no further than Japan to see the evidence of stagnant birth rates. Prolonged periods of economic stagnation and decline. Why is that the case? Well, as birth rates slow, average population age increases. More and more old people need to be supported by fewer and fewer young people. However, as we’ve already seen, the current younger generation has little interest in caring for older generations. They have little interests beyond their own school/career. As the work force gets smaller, it becomes harder and harder to find suitable labor, driving up the cost of labor (which is still very low by world standards, but has increased rapidly in the last decade). Western countries have countered declining birth rates by substituting immigration for natural growth, but Asian countries like Japan and China are not multicultural, immigrant-fueled countries. china will not open its doors to immigrating cheap labor (though there are few restrictions on people like me - “professional” talent).
So what is the tl;dr of all of this? Well, you can’t just sum up China in the way you normally hear it portrayed. Yes, the economic growth has been a “miracle” - but when people make predictions that it will pass up the US in 20 years, these are based on assumptions that growth will continue at the same rate it has. That is a pretty weighty assumption. There are a lot of issues just bubbling at the surface. I can’t wait to see how it plays out.